Mazzucato and Piketty support stronger EU wage law

Two of Europe’s leading economists are supporting calls for a strong EU directive on adequate minimum wages as a crucial part of the recovery from the Covid crisis.

In a significant intervention which coincides with the EU social summit in Porto, an open letter signed by professors Mariana Mazzucato and Thomas Piketty says the directive represents a “paradigm shift” in European Commission policy compared to its response to the financial crisis.

Welcoming the directive, the economists argue that backing minimum wages with legislation would genuinely ensure people in work would no longer live below the poverty line.

The letter, which is also signed by other renowned economists from across Europe, concludes:

“The proposed Directive is a step in the right direction, but stronger measures are needed to guarantee the respect of the right to collective bargaining for unions to negotiate better pay and conditions for workers and raise statutory minimum wages to a level which ensures at least a decent standard of living. Adequate minimum wages and strong collective bargaining are not only good for the people, they are clearly also good for the economy.”

Currently, statutory minimum wages in 20 EU member states are set so low that the changes trade unions ask for would entail much-needed wage increases for more than 24 million workers.

Working poverty is also rising in Europe as the result of at least 3 million people losing the benefits of collectively bargained wages and working conditions since 2000. The evidence shows that countries with low levels of workers covered by collective bargaining have the lowest wages. 

The co-rapporteurs from the European Parliament, supported by trade unions and now top economists, have tabled amendments to strengthen the directive which include:  

- A “threshold of decency” which would ensure that statutory minimum wages cannot be set less than 60% of the median wage and 50% of the average wage in member states

- Ensuring that the award of public contracts is only to companies that respect the right of workers to join a union and collectively bargain

- Giving unions the right to access workplaces and protection against union-busting by employers

The ETUC has also received a message of support from Professor James K Galbraith, who said:

"As an economist and student of comparative systems, I can say categorically that countries and regions with high minimum wages, strong unions and labor standards have better economic performance, including lower unemployment, than those lacking in these regards. For this reason, I have always strongly supported movements to raise the minimum wage and strengthen labor rights in the United States.”

“Many of Europe’s most respected economists are saying loud and clear that increasing minimum wages is good for the economy” said Esther Lynch, ETUC Deputy General Secretary. “It is an important message for the EU and member states at this time when the Directive on Adequate Minimum Wages is being discussed in the European Parliament and when the EU is holding its first Social Summit for many years.”

Full letter in English, French, German and Dutch

List of signatories:

  • Prof. Mariana Mazzucato, Professor in the Economics of Innovation and Public Value, Founding Director, Institute for Innovation and Public Purpose (IIPP), University College London (UCL), Italy/UK
  • Prof. Thomas Piketty, Professor at the EHESS and at the Paris School of Economics, Co-director, World Inequality Lab/World Inequality Database, France
  • Prof. Sebastian Dullien, Research Director, Macroeconomic Policy Institute, IMK, Hans-Böckler-Stiftung, Professor for International Economics, HTW Berlin - University of Applied Sciences, Germany
  • Prof. Paul De Grauwe, John Paulson Chair in European Political Economy, European Institute, London School of Economics, Belgium/UK
  • Prof. Thorsten Schulten, Head of the Collective Agreements Archive of the Economic and Social Research, WSI, Hans-Böckler-Stiftung, Honorary Professor at the University of Tübingen, Germany
  • Lord Meghnad Desai, Economist, House of Lords, UK
  • Michel Husson, Economist, IRES, France
  • Prof. Ozlem Onaran, Professor of Economics, Co-Director of Institute of Political Economy, Governance, Finance and Accountability, University of Greenwich, UK
  • Prof. Mario Pianta, Professor of Economic Policy, Scuola Normale Superiore, Florence, Italy
  • Prof. Julie Froud, University of Manchester, Professor of Financial Innovation is a member of the Organisations and Society subject group in the People, Management and Organisations division of MBS, UK
  • Dr Dirk Ehnts, Economist, Technical University of Chemnitz, Germany
  • Dr Tom McDonnell, Co-director, Nevin Economic Research Institute, Dublin, Ireland
  • Dr Philipp Heimberger, Economist, Wiener Institut für Internationale Wirtschaftsvergleiche, Austria
  • Dr Dario Guarascio, Deparment of economics and law - Sapienza University of Rome, Italy
  • Dr Christos Pierros, Post-doctoral researcher, University of Athens and Senior Researcher INE GSEE, Greece
  • Dr Jorge Uxó, Associate professor, University of Castilla - La Mancha, Spain
  • Dr Angelo Salento, Associate professor of Economic sociology and Sociology of work, University of Salento, Italy